C2 / 15.79% of index

Evidence artifact

Does it produce a portable, verifiable record of what was found?

What is evidence artifact?

An evidence artifact is a portable record of discovery results, such as a CycloneDX cryptographic bill of materials, that can be validated and reused outside the product interface.

A dashboard assertion is not the same as durable evidence. Schema validation, hashes, signatures and public verification procedures determine whether another party can prove the artifact is complete and unaltered.

Questions to ask a vendor

  1. Can the complete artifact be downloaded?
  2. Does it validate against a named schema?
  3. Can an unaffiliated third party verify integrity without contacting the vendor?

What this edition actually supports

Weight 3 of 19. Can a reviewer carry the finding away and verify its structure and custody?

A CBOM or equivalent export is useful when it identifies the product/build, records findings, states its source and can be checked against a public format. The QScout 9 in the frozen edition includes a signed sample from its own API; that sample is not a customer-estate Gold scan. A separately published owned one-file lab packet shows what its local, unreleased export repair produced, including an incomplete after inventory.

How to investigate this criterion

Inspect the actual artifact, schema, signature scope, verifier and the difference between sample, lab and production output.

The 2026.7 cells below are public-evidence scores. A vendor page documents a claim; an artifact check tests only its stated scope. Missing product execution and inaccessible sources remain explicit unknowns. The score snapshot has not been recomputed from later pages.

Evidence artifact scores in edition 2026.7

Equal scores share the same criterion position; the next position skips the tied places. The highest value in this column is a published rubric cell, not a measured product winner. A partial or unverified source anchor remains visible even when its numeric score is high.

Position on criterionProductEvidence artifact scoreOverall scoreInternal 1 October source reviewEvidence
1QScout Pulse GoldQtonic Quantum Corp98.00Narrow public artifact checkedSeparate public 13-component own-API CBOM sample was schema/signature/tamper checked; this is not an estate Gold native scan.Exact cell and citationsS27S28S29S30
2CBOM SecureEncryption Consulting77.47Narrow feature documentedAccessible vendor page documents CycloneDX 1.6/1.7 export; it does not document a signature on the exported CBOM.Exact cell and citationsS04S05S06
3Keyfactor AgileSec + CommandKeyfactor66.53Narrow feature documentedVendor explicitly documents CycloneDX CBOM 1.6 export per source, without export signature.Exact cell and citationsS08S25
3QCecuring CBOMQCecuring66.53Narrow feature documentedPublic documentation explicitly specifies CycloneDX 1.6 JSON output; no integrity mechanism cited.Exact cell and citationsS19
3AppViewX Quantum Trust HubAppViewX66.37Claim not verified from accessible evidenceVendor blog/docs/datasheet returned 403; CycloneDX/CSV export claim remains unverified here.Exact cell and citationsS07S24
3Fortanix Key Insight / PQC CentralFortanix65.74Narrow feature documentedVendor explicitly documents CycloneDX CBOM JSON export across named environments; no signed-export mechanism.Exact cell and citationsS15
3IBM Guardium + Quantum SafeIBM65.58Narrow feature documentedIBM documentation describes CBOM/CSV/Findings.JSON output; no signature/integrity method cited.Exact cell and citationsS09S10S26
3O3 SecurityO3 Security65.47Claim not verified from accessible evidenceArchived generic industry-format quote does not name CycloneDX; exact standard-schema export support unverified.Exact cell and citationsS17
3QuSecure QuProtect R3QuSecure65.21Narrow feature documentedVendor documents CycloneDX 1.6 CBOM export from live inventory; exported bytes were not tested.Exact cell and citationsS13
3CryptoNext COMPASSCryptoNext64.68Narrow feature documentedPrimary Network Probe PDF states CBOM files based on OWASP CycloneDX; PDF text extraction splits the standard name.Exact cell and citationsS16
11SandboxAQ AQtive GuardSandboxAQ46.21Narrow feature documentedCSV export is documented; marketed CBOM mechanism lacks version/sample, so stronger standard-export claim is withheld.Exact cell and citationsS12
11DigiCert Quantum CentralDigiCert45.37Narrow feature documentedVendor documents export for offline use, without a standard-schema CBOM or integrity mechanism in cited material.Exact cell and citationsS18
11TYCHON Quantum CommandTYCHON45.16Claim not verified from accessible evidenceVendor pages returned 403; third-party integration PR does not prove a product CycloneDX export.Exact cell and citationsS11
14ISARA AdvanceISARA35.42Partial or qualified supportPrimary Azure whitepaper documents dashboards/APIs but no explicit standard/proprietary export; midpoint three is discretionary.Exact cell and citationsS14